We understand that this can be confusing sometimes. Our products are 100% natural and like leaves on a tree, no two will be exactly alike. We follow the same recipe on all our products but sometimes the color may change due to a number of reasons. For one, something as simple as the room temperature in our lab can change the color of a soap during the saponification process, that's the chemical process that occurs when the ingredients are combined to create soap. Second, we can get two bottles of the exact same oil from one of our suppliers and both bottles could be two different colors. That's the beauty of natural products, you never know how the end product is going to turn out.
When/if we have a soap that comes out looking less than gorgeous, well put those on super sale. There's nothing wrong with them, we just don't like the look of them. Same great formula, just not the prettiest.